Money
Come
  • Management
  • Performance
  • Create an investment
  •  nickname
    nickname
    Management Performance Custom Category Setting Account Setting
    Logout
  • Sign Up
  • Sign In
Social Index Piggy Hotspots Piggy Rich Free Hot Compound Interest News  Site Articles  Div. Overview Wise Tool  Compound Interest Calc.  Compound Interest Cf.  Stock Portfolio  Finalcial Crisis  Stock Analysis  Record Retrieval  Dividend Calc.  More ...
  1. MoneyCome.in
  2. Article Categories
  3. 存股複利
{"type":0,"nickname":"MoneyCome.in","title":"哪種存股好?成長股、定存股,或景氣循環股? | 資產類型複利比較","myCatId":"5d6299023286fe05f50e6bd8","myCatName":"存股複利","preview":{"essayId":"5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe","at":"s3","imgId":"5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png"}},"intro":"#### 資產類型 ####\n\n股票(資產)大致分成幾種類型\n1、成長股:穩穩的每年成長\n2、定存股:穩穩的每年都是一樣的表現\n3、景氣循環股:每3~5年一個循環,有高低點轉換\n## 存哪種類型? ##\n\n存股族經常會問\n到底要存成長股、定存股、或景氣循環股呢?\n\n會有這樣的疑問,主因存股族最終的目","hashtags":["#單位數"],"browsingCnt":3029,"createTime":1590394646716,"essayDate":"2020-05-25","essayTime":1590364800000,"lastModify":1590399426370,"essayId":"5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe","sets":[{"imgId":"5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496","at":"s3","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb919f3286fe2acb9d8496.png"},"text":"#### 資產類型 ####\n\n股票(資產)大致分成幾種類型\n1、成長股:穩穩的每年成長\n2、定存股:穩穩的每年都是一樣的表現\n3、景氣循環股:每3~5年一個循環,有高低點轉換","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":1.4148,"w":1030,"h":728,"setId":"5ecb87983286fe108af11681"},{"imgId":"","at":"","url":{"large":"","medium":"","small":"","thumbnail":""},"text":"## 存哪種類型? ##\n\n存股族經常會問\n到底要存成長股、定存股、或景氣循環股呢?\n\n會有這樣的疑問,主因存股族最終的目標是希望得到更多的被動收入\n\n成長股因成本愈墊愈高,定期定額買到的單位數愈來愈少;\n反之,景氣循環股可趁股價低迷時買入更多的#單位數,是不是更快達到目標呢?\n\n本文將以簡單的數學進行回答","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"setId":"5ecb87983286fe108af11682"},{"imgId":"","at":"","url":{"large":"","medium":"","small":"","thumbnail":""},"text":"#### 成長股 vs 景氣循環股 ####\n\n首先使用MoneyCome提供的比較工具,進行比較\n(工具: https://www.moneycome.in/tool/which_asset_type )\n並採用以下假設:\n(1)\n【本金100萬元、年投入6萬元(相當於5000元/月)、執行期間20年】\n(2)\n成長股 :年成長10.0 %,現金股利5.0 %\n景氣循環股:年波動100 %,現金股利7.5 %\n定存股 :年成長0 %,現金股利6.0 %\n","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"setId":"5ecb87983286fe108af11683"},{"imgId":"5ecb84a13286fe1091f10376","at":"s3","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb84a13286fe1091f10376.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb84a13286fe1091f10376.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb84a13286fe1091f10376.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb84a13286fe1091f10376.png"},"text":"以市值來說,有幾個現象:\n\n1.\n景氣循環股在20年期間,總共經過3個循環\n在第一個環循(C1)時,前五年都能勝過成長股\n在第二個環循(C2)時,前四年都能勝過成長股,第五年開始輸\n在第三個環循(C3)時,前三年都能勝過成長股,第四年開始輸\n\n簡單的結論就是\n成長股的複利效應,愈後面表現愈強\n基本不是景氣循環股可以追的上的\n\n2.\n景氣循環股的波動,愈後面波動愈大\n在C1循環時,高低差在590萬~190萬間,波動-400萬\n同期間成長股約190萬~320萬,波動+130萬\n在C3循環時,高低差在1600萬~510萬間,波動-1090萬\n同期間成長股約1300萬~2000萬,波動+700萬\n\n景氣循環股正負波動太大,隨著複利效應,波動更大\n成長股則是不斷正成長\n長期持有景氣循環股的投資者,心理面的考驗更大\n","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":1.3438,"w":1032,"h":768,"setId":"5ecb87983286fe108af11684"},{"imgId":"5ecb88ce3286fe108af11759","at":"s3","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb88ce3286fe108af11759.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb88ce3286fe108af11759.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb88ce3286fe108af11759.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb88ce3286fe108af11759.png"},"text":"以每年領取的股利來說,幾個現象和市值也蠻類似的\n\n1.\n景氣循環股在20年期間,總共經過3個循環\n每次循環,將愈提早輸給成長股\n\n2.\n景氣循環股的波動,愈後面波動愈大\n在C1循環時,高低差在40萬~13萬間,波動-27萬\n同期間成長股約17萬~29萬,波動+12萬\n在C3循環時,高低差在110萬~35萬間,波動-75萬\n同期間成長股約110萬~180萬,波動+70萬\n\n景氣循環股正負波動太大,隨著複利效應,波動更大\n成長股的股利不斷正成長\n試想,持有景氣循環股,每年領的股利最高110萬,最低35萬\n這樣的生活適合退休生活嗎?\n","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":1.3154,"w":1026,"h":780,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d8176"},{"imgId":"","at":"","url":{"large":"","medium":"","small":"","thumbnail":""},"text":"## 小結 ##\n\n單純討論數學模型時\n成長股比較適合長期持有,但也不是說不能持有景氣循環股\n在有把握抓到景氣區間的情況,景氣循環股賺的還是比較快\n但要懂的在高點放手,考驗的是投資人的智慧","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d8177"},{"imgId":"","at":"","url":{"large":"","medium":"","small":"","thumbnail":""},"text":"#### 景氣循環 vs 大跌大買 ####\n\n再來會衍申另一個問題\n由上述結果,景氣循環股用定期定額的方式顯然不明智\n如果大跌時大買呢?有沒有機會贏過成長股?","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d8178"},{"imgId":"5ecb90033286fe2acb9d8231","at":"s3","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb90033286fe2acb9d8231.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb90033286fe2acb9d8231.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb90033286fe2acb9d8231.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb90033286fe2acb9d8231.png"},"text":"## 崩盤再加碼 ##\n\n我們使用MoneyCome的工具「崩盤再加碼」的選項\n並假設這位投資人資金配置時,一開始本金為100萬元\n等待景氣不佳時,隨時加碼100萬元 (好威^^\")","layout":1,"from":0,"aspectRatio":1.2246,"w":1014,"h":828,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d8179"},{"imgId":"5ecb916d3286fe2acb9d8492","at":"s3","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb916d3286fe2acb9d8492.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb916d3286fe2acb9d8492.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb916d3286fe2acb9d8492.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb916d3286fe2acb9d8492.png"},"text":"## 景氣循環股的投資績效 ##\n\n崩盤再加碼的效果,果然可以改善景氣循環股用定期定額績效不佳的問題","layout":1,"from":0,"aspectRatio":1.4251,"w":1009,"h":708,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d817a"},{"imgId":"5ecb8e403286fe2acb9d8074","at":"s3","url":{"large":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/l_5ecb8e403286fe2acb9d8074.png","medium":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/m_5ecb8e403286fe2acb9d8074.png","small":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb8e403286fe2acb9d8074.png","thumbnail":"https://tipga.s3-ap-northeast-1.amazonaws.com/0/MoneyCome.in/s_5ecb8e403286fe2acb9d8074.png"},"text":"## 付出成本 ##\n\n使用「崩盤再加碼」的選項\n雖然可以彌補績效不穩的問題,但付出的成本可是非常驚人的\n\n成長股的部份\n因為數學假設的關係,並沒有崩盤的問題,所以沒有加碼的時機\n\n景氣循環股的部份\n在景氣往下時,基本上是年年加碼\n以本例來說,共三個循環,歷經9年景氣低迷,共加碼900萬\n雖然看似彌補了績效不佳的問題,但如果計算年化報酬率,還是慘輸","layout":1,"from":0,"aspectRatio":2.3767,"w":1022,"h":430,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d817b"},{"imgId":"","at":"","url":{"large":"","medium":"","small":"","thumbnail":""},"text":"年化報酬率可以解釋為投資本金運用的效率\n雖然感覺有追上成長股,但付出的成本巨大\n效率自然低","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"setId":"5ecb8f863286fe2acb9d817c"},{"imgId":"","at":"","url":{"large":"","medium":"","small":"","thumbnail":""},"text":"#### 結論 ####\n\n景氣循環股:\n景氣好時賺的快,景氣差時跌的猛\n若能在景氣谷底時小額配置一些,也能參與景氣繁榮的果實\n\n成長股:\n如同巴菲特說的滾雪球,愈後面愈吃香\n\n經由本文的分析\n存股族適合什麼樣類型的股票呢?\n留給大家自行思考^_^","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"setId":"5ecb90ac3286fe2acb9d83d6"},{"imgId":"","at":"parseUrl","url":{"large":"https://www.moneycome.in/tool/which_asset_type","medium":"https://www.moneycome.in/tool/which_asset_type","small":"https://www.moneycome.in/tool/which_asset_type","thumbnail":"https://www.moneycome.in/tool/which_asset_type"},"text":"MoneyCome提供不同資產類型的複利試算,讓投資者更清楚知道該選擇什麼類型的資產進行長期投資。","layout":0,"from":0,"aspectRatio":-1,"w":-1,"h":-1,"parseUrlResult":{"title":"\n 資產類型比較 - 成長股或景氣循環股? - MoneyCome.in\n ","description":"MoneyCome提供不同資產類型的複利試算,讓投資者更清楚知道該選擇什麼類型的資產進行長期投資。","host":"www.moneycome.in","url":"https://www.moneycome.in/tool/which_asset_type","charset":"utf-8","og:title":"資產類型比較 - 成長股或景氣循環股? @[ MoneyCome.in ]","og:description":"MoneyCome提供不同資產類型的複利試算,讓投資者更清楚知道該選擇什麼類型的資產進行長期投資。","og:image":"https://www.moneycome.in/img/pic/which_asset_type.png","first_img":"https://www.moneycome.in//img/portfolio.png","preview_img":"https://www.moneycome.in/img/pic/which_asset_type.png"},"setId":"5ecb91a33286fe2acb9d84a5"}],"originalLinkHint":{"en":{"text":"Orignal Link: https://www.tipga.com/e/5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe","html":"\u003cdiv class=\"originalLinkHintWrapper tOverflow\"\u003eOrignal Link: \u003ca href=\"https://www.tipga.com/e/5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe\" target=\"_blank\"\u003ehttps://www.tipga.com/e/5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe\u003c/a\u003e\u003c/div\u003e"},"zh_TW":{"text":"原文連結:https://www.tipga.com/e/5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe","html":"\u003cdiv class=\"originalLinkHintWrapper tOverflow\"\u003e原文連結:\u003ca href=\"https://www.tipga.com/e/5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe\" target=\"_blank\"\u003ehttps://www.tipga.com/e/5ecb7f163286fe1091f102fe\u003c/a\u003e\u003c/div\u003e"}},"apiFooter":{"en":{"text":"Tipga - Enjoy Writing, Enrich Life!","html":"\u003cdiv class=\"originalLinkHintWrapper tOverflow\"\u003e\u003cspan style=\"color:#ffaa33;\"\u003eTipga\u003c/span\u003e - Enjoy Writing, Enrich Life! \u003ca href=\"https://www.tipga.com\" target=\"_blank\"\u003ehttps://www.tipga.com\u003c/a\u003e\u003c/div\u003e"},"zh_TW":{"text":"Tipga - 享受寫作,豐富生活!","html":"\u003cdiv class=\"originalLinkHintWrapper tOverflow\"\u003e\u003cspan style=\"color:#ffaa33;\"\u003eTipga\u003c/span\u003e - 享受寫作,豐富生活! \u003ca href=\"https://www.tipga.com\" target=\"_blank\"\u003ehttps://www.tipga.com\u003c/a\u003e\u003c/div\u003e"}}}

投資記帳,股票記帳,股市記帳,投資記錄,交易記錄,股市交易記錄

Investment accounting

  • MoneyCome.in
  • |
  • Q&A
  • |
  • Contact Us